GREAT EMBOLDENING: Aspiring authoritarians get a Trump boost

WASHINGTON: When President Joe Biden convened democracy summits at the White House in 2021 and 2023, he pointedly disinvited Turkish President Recep Tayyip Erdogan, a man he had once described as an “autocrat” who deserved to be driven from office by voters.

On Tuesday, President Donald Trump offered a much rosier assessment of Erdogan, even as protesters filled the streets after the arrest of the mayor of Istanbul, Erdogan’s chief political rival.

“A good leader,” Trump said of Erdogan during a meeting of his ambassadors at the White House. He made no mention of the arrest or the protests.

Since taking office Jan. 20, Trump has turned a central precept of American diplomacy on its head. He is embracing — rather than denouncing — fellow leaders who abandon democratic principles. The long-standing bipartisan effort to bolster democratic institutions around the world has been replaced by a president who praises leaders who move toward autocracy.

And Trump’s own actions — taking revenge against his political rivals, attacking law firms, journalists and universities, and questioning the authority of the judiciary — are offering new models for democratically elected leaders in countries such as Serbia and Israel who have already shown a willingness to push the boundaries of their institutions.

“There’s a great emboldening,” said Rosa Balfour, the Europe director for the Carnegie Endowment for International Peace. “What Trump says reverberates strongly here. But also what the United States does not do. It does not punish or condemn any attempt to undermine the rule of law or democracy. There are no repercussions.”

Jane Harman, a former member of Congress and former president of the Woodrow Wilson International Center for Scholars, noted that Erdogan and other leaders around the world had been “drifting away” from democratic principles for years.

In 2016, a faction in Erdogan’s government attempted a coup to overthrow him. Since then, he has tightened control of the presidency by attacking the media, political opponents, the courts and other institutions.

“This has become a very different world, but I don’t think Trump started it, and I don’t think Trump is going to end it either,” Harman said. And she noted that in at least a few places, Trump’s return to power had prompted some voters to question the authoritarian leanings of candidates and parties.

“Think Germany,” she said, referring to recent elections in the country. “The far right has risen in popularity, but it didn’t win. And the backlash to Trump might have been part of the momentum that held it back.”

Trump is not the first president to tolerate less-than-democratic actions from allies when they deem it necessary.

Biden offered a fist-bump to Crown Prince Mohammed bin Salman, Saudi Arabia’s de facto ruler, even as Biden blamed him for the murder of columnist Jamal Khashoggi. Biden also worked with Indian Prime Minister Narendra Modi, who has increasingly cracked down on dissent in his country, and — at times — with Erdogan.

But Trump’s election has coincided with actions by elected leaders that appear to depart from the kind of democratic principles that America stood for.

In Israel, Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu no longer needs to contend with Biden’s opposition to a long-planned overhaul of the courts, which many Israelis view as an attempt to control and politicize the judiciary. In 2023, Biden told reporters that Netanyahu “cannot continue down this road” of judicial changes.

With Trump in office, the Israeli leader faces no such pressure. This month, he fired the chief of the country’s domestic intelligence agency, a move seen as undermining its independence. Later, the Cabinet approved a vote of no confidence in the country’s attorney general, prompting fresh accusations that Netanyahu is curbing the independence of the justice system, purging officials he considers disloyal. On Thursday, Netanyahu’s allies in parliament voted to give themselves more power over the selection of the country’s judges. The vote came after Netanyahu gave a speech echoing Trump and saying that the action meant that “the deep state is in danger.”

“The US is not going to put any pressure whatsoever on Netanyahu to respect the democratic institutions of his own country,” Balfour said. “Netanyahu feels that he has impunity in that respect.”

In Serbia, President Aleksandar Vucic has spent years attacking the media and other political opponents. Last month, as Trump dismantled the US Agency for International Development, Vucic sent police to raid organizations in his country, some of which had received money from the now largely shuttered US agency.

Authorities in Vucic’s government cited Trump’s actions in the United States as justification for moving against the organizations, including the Centre for Research, Transparency and Accountability and Civic Initiatives. They quoted Elon Musk, the multibillionaire who is running the so-called Department of Government Efficiency, who claimed, without evidence, that USAID was a “criminal organization.”

This month, after Erdogan’s government jailed the mayor of Istanbul, one of Trump’s senior diplomatic envoys spoke positively about Turkey’s leader during an interview with former Fox News host Tucker Carlson.

“Really transformational,” Steve Witkoff said of a recent telephone call between Trump and Erdogan. “There’s just a lot of good, positive news coming out of Turkey right now as a result of that conversation.”

Ruth Ben-Ghiat, a professor of history at New York University, said Trump’s words and actions — and those of his surrogates — are being watched by other leaders. She said the president’s lack of condemnation of Erdogan after the arrest of the Istanbul mayor would have been noted by authoritarian-leaning presidents and prime ministers.

“The moves of Trump in this same direction,” she said, “embolden foreign leaders who know the U.S. is now an autocratic ally, and there will be no consequences for repressive behaviour.”

The New York Times